| Date | Opponent | Notes | Result | Status | Links |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| September | |||||
| Mon. 2 | vs. Andrews University | L, 4-3 | Final | ||
| Thu. 5 | vs. Wabash | L, 1-0 | Final | ||
| Tue. 10 | at Muskingum | L, 2-0 | Final | ||
| Sat. 14 | at Wittenberg | L, 4-0 | Final | ||
| Wed. 18 | vs. Waynesburg | L, 4-3 | Final | ||
| Fri. 20 | vs. Calvin | L, 5-0 | Final | ||
| Mon. 23 | at Oberlin | L, 7-0 | Final | ||
| October | |||||
| Sun. 6 | vs. Rose-Hulman * @ Lima, OH | L, 5-0 | Final | ||
| Wed. 9 | at Mt. St. Joseph * | L, 2-1 | Final - OT | ||
| Sat. 12 | at Earlham * | L, 1-0 | Final | ||
| Wed. 16 | vs. Anderson (Ind.) * | L, 3-2 | Final | ||
| Sat. 19 | vs. Hanover * | L, 2-0 | Final | ||
| Wed. 23 | at Manchester * | L, 2-1 | Final | ||
| Sat. 26 | at Franklin * | W, 1-0 | Final - OT | ||
| Wed. 30 | vs. Defiance * | L, 2-1 | Final | ||
| November | |||||
| Sat. 2 | at Transylvania * | L, 6-1 | Final | ||