| 2024 Cole Kropka | 1993 Mike Minnig |
| 2023 Jack Towell | 1992 Mike Evans |
| 2022 Jameel Cosby | 1991 Jon Friesen |
| 2021 Patrick Spillman | 1990 Bill Sammons |
| 2020 Andrew Renner | 1989 Cliff Hemmert |
| 2019 Isaac Zickafoose | 1988 Rob Roeschley |
| 2018 Ryan Golden | 1987 John Mast, Pete DuMonte |
| 2017 Trey Elchert | 1986 Doug Sanders, Ed Coleman |
| 2016 Ryan Aelker | 1985 Tim Walters |
| 2015 Ryan Leopold | 1984 Todd Hafner |
| 2014 Shawn Frost | 1983 Doug Fries |
| 2013 Thomas Gingrich | 1982 Greg Kutz |
| 2012 Andrew Chaffee, Todd Trotter | 1981 Darrell Buroker |
| 2011 Rob Luderman | 1980 Abe Groves |
| 2010 Cody McPherson | 1979 Richard Bindernagel |
| 2009 Kyle Rode | 1978 Richard Mitterholzer |
| 2008 Tim Kay | 1977 Dave Repp |
| 2007 Mike Anthony | 1976 Jim King |
| 2006 Scott Bergman | 1975 Denny Ramseyer |
| 2005 Scott Steiner | 1974 Jim Roach |
| 2004 Brad Boyles | 1973 Rick Shaner |
| 2003 Brad Moore | 1972 Errol Miller |
| 2002 Brad Buckingham | 1971 Jack Arnold |
| 2001 Jeremy Roberts | 1970 Denny Lane |
| 2000 Eric Metz | 1969 Greg Clemens |
| 1999 Ben Simcox | 1968 Bruce Wasem |
| 1998 David Sheldon | 1967 Dave Enz |
| 1997 Scott Minnig | 1966 Alex Clark |
| 1996 Jonathan Kirkton | 1965 Charles Buroker |
| 1995 Jamie Yount | 1964 Dale Schiffke |
| 1994 Todd Kirkton | 1963 Dennis Bishop |
| 1962 Bill Lape | |